American Express Denies Downgrade
One of the things we stress frequently in this hobby is evaluating annual fees. Annual fees are almost always worth it in year one. But as part of the annual evaluation process, we also stress looking at downgrade options. American Express has historically been great about allowing downgrades on many cards, as we cover in our guide. However, I recently ran into quite the opposite: American Express denied me the ability to downgrade a card.

The Card
The annual fee on my Delta SkyMiles® Platinum Business American Express Card posted in October. As I usually do, I put a reminder on my calendar for the week of November 9th so I wouldn’t forget to call. I had already checked for a retention offer, but nothing was available. I also always verify the last day to cancel with the agent.
The Chat
On November 11th, I decided to chat with American Express and downgrade to the Delta SkyMiles® Gold Business American Express Card.
Everything started normally. Then the agent said they were checking on the request. I sensed something was off based on the delay and the phrasing. Then came the shocking statement: “For now, the downgrade request is not available for your card Richard.”

When I pushed back a bit and asked if they would rather I close the card than downgrade it, the representative wouldn’t say much beyond acknowledging that they understood. I have no idea what that means.

I pushed back again, asking why downgrades weren’t allowed, but the representative either couldn’t or wouldn’t give me an answer.
What I Did
I immediately shifted some credit from the card to another American Express business card. While it’s a business card and the credit limit doesn’t impact my personal credit report, it had the highest limit of any of my American Express cards. I wanted to preserve that credit limit, especially if I needed to recon any future applications.
Next, I used the little bit of SkyMiles I had to book a couple of placeholder flights. By booking before canceling the card, I was able to lock in the 15% discount for having an eligible Delta card. Those bookings remained valid after I canceled, giving me the discount even though I no longer held the card.
After taking care of those things, I canceled the card. I asked about downgrading again, but it still wasn’t an option.
My History
There are a couple of things about my American Express history that I think are important and may be useful data points.
Before canceling the Delta card, I had five American Express credit cards, so I was maxed out under the five-card rule. Those included three Hilton cards, one Marriott card, and the Delta card. I also have three other American Express cards, what we would refer to as pay-over-time cards.
I’ve also closed two other American Express cards this year. One was the Business Platinum Card® from American Express, as I’ve been trying to cut down on all the coupons. The other was an American Express® Green Card, which no longer offered enough benefit for me to keep it.
I don’t know if any of this played a role in the downgrade denial, but I thought it was worth sharing.
American Express Denies Downgrade: ToP Thoughts
We’ve frequently seen this with Capital One, where you have to be “eligible” for a downgrade, but not with American Express. I’m not sure why American Express wouldn’t allow me to downgrade this card, especially when the alternative was closing it altogether.
Let’s hope this isn’t a new trend. Have you had this happen before? Come over to the Facebook group and let us know.
